How to Ensure Competitive Freight Pricing: What a Recent Lawsuit Means for Shippers

The recent federal lawsuit over broker transparency has reignited industry-wide discussions about pricing opacity in freight brokerage. While the case is centered around carrier access to broker records, mid-size shippers should take note – this legal battle highlights the importance of securing competitive rates in an environment where margins often remain hidden.

The Issue at Hand: Broker Transparency and Carrier Rights

At the heart of the lawsuit is the alleged failure to comply with a federal order requiring brokers to provide carriers with transactional records upon request. Carriers argue that hidden margins prevent them from negotiating fairly, while brokers contend that confidentiality and negotiated contracts should allow them to operate freely.

For shippers, however, broker margins are usually a secondary concern. Their primary goal is securing reliable, cost-efficient freight transportation. Broker margins may often not be top of mind for many shippers, their primary concern is typically reliable, cost-effective freight transportation with reasonable service. The question a shipper should ask is, "Are we getting the best service at the best rate?"

Why Shippers Should Care

While this lawsuit doesn’t directly impact shippers, it raises the broader issue of pricing opacity in freight brokerage. If brokers have excessive markups, shippers could unknowingly be paying above-market rates. Without visibility into multiple pricing options, they risk overpaying for transportation.

That said, good brokers provide a critical service by handling logistics complexities, managing carrier relationships, and ensuring efficient freight movement. Their margins reflect the value they bring to the supply chain. The key is not eliminating broker profits but ensuring that pricing remains competitive and fair for all parties involved.

How Shippers Can Take Control

Rather than focusing on broker margins, shippers should prioritize securing competitive pricing across multiple brokers. This is where technology solutions like Portex come into play. While we don’t reveal broker margins, we make it easy for shippers to benchmark rates and ensure they’re getting fair pricing. Here’s how:

1. Compare across brokers: Portex allows shippers to receive and compare rates from multiple brokers in one platform, ensuring they aren’t over-reliant on a single provider.
2. Benchmark freight costs: With historical data on lanes and pricing trends, shippers can assess whether their quoted rates align with market trends, and their own booking history.
3. Streamline the bidding process: Instead of relying on back-and-forth emails or phone calls, Portex centralizes negotiations, saving time and effort while enhancing rate competition.
4. Gain Market Intelligence: By tracking past pricing trends over 15, 30, and 60 days, shippers can understand how rates are shifting and make informed decisions.

The Bottom Line: While The Debate Around Transparency Continues, Shippers Need Competitive Pricing

Many freight brokers provide a valuable service, and their margins are a natural part of the business. The key for shippers may not necessarily be to see those margins, but to ensure they are getting cost-competitive rates by leveraging multiple brokers and historical pricing data.

With cases like this bringing transparency issues into the spotlight, shippers must be proactive in securing the best deals. Technology-driven solutions like Portex empower mid-size shippers to take control of their freight spend – without getting caught up in the broker transparency debate.

If you’re looking to optimize your freight costs and ensure competitive rates, Portex can help you navigate the complexities of freight pricing with confidence. 

‍